This is "by request", both Dylan and Paul Simon sets.
I do not have any source info....download a track and see if you like the quality.  

While I have your attention....I would like to fill in 1995 during this shelter from the new show storm.  Anyone have any of the folllwing shows?

May
10 San Diego, 
18 Hollywood, 
19 Hollywood,
20 Santa Barbara, 
26 Berkeley, 
28 Reno, 
30 Eugene,Check for Completeness 
31 Eugene 

June
2 Seattle, 
4 Seattle, 
6 Portland, 
19 East Rutherford,  
 
July 4 Berlin,  
September 29 Sunrise, 

October 
7 Charleston,
9 Savannah, 
11 Atlanta, 
14 Biloxi, 
15 Thibodaux, 
18 Birmingham,
19 Memphis, 
24 Minneapolis, 
29 Springfield, 
 
November
1 Houston, 
3 San Antonio, 
4 Austin, 
9 Phoenix, 
10 Las Vegas, 
19 Los Angeles 

Here's that setlist you've been looking for:

Bob Dylan
September 12, 1999 
Lafayette, Louisiana
University Of Southwestern, Louisiana, The Cajundome

Disc 1

I Am The Man, Thomas @
Mr. Tambourine Man @
It's Alright, Ma (I'm Only Bleeding) @
To Ramona @
Tangled Up In Blue @
All Along The Watchtower 
Positively 4th Street 
Silvio 
Not Dark Yet 
Highway 61 Revisited 

Disc 2

Bob Dylan's Encore

Like A Rolling Stone 
It Ain't Me, Babe 
The Boxer *
That'll Be The Day/The Wanderer *
Knockin' On Heaven's Door *

*Duet with Paul Simon

Paul Simon's Encore

Late In The Evening 
Still Crazy After All These years 
That Was Your Mother * 
The Sound Of Silence 

* Joined on this song by 3 local Cajun-Zydeco 
musicians: Terrance Simien on accordian, a 
washboard player (possibly one of the members 
of Terrance Simien's Mallet Playboy Band),
and an unidentified blind saxophone player. 

Disc 3

Bridge Over Troubled Water 
Can't Run But 
The Boy In The Bubble 
The Coast 
Trailway Bus 
Mrs. Robinson 
Me And Julio Down By The Schoolyard 
Further To Fly 
Graceland 
The Cool, Cool River 
Slip Sliding Away 
Diamonds On The Soles Of Her Shoes 
You Can Call Me Al